OPINION
OPINION

India’s Job Creation Challenge

What are the major concerns of Indians today? According to the December issue of Ipsos, the global market research and public opinion specialist, the three burning headaches of urban Indians are unemployment (41%), financial and political corruption (29%) and coronavirus (29%). These are followed by urban Indian worries about crime and violence (25%) and poverty and social inequality (25%). India is one of the 26 countries that feature in Ispos periodic review of citizens’ perception as to whether the things are moving in the “right direction” or “are they off on the wrong track?”

One can always make an issue of the quality and breadth of the survey sample size and how good are interviewers in engaging interviewees in discussions. Whatever that may be, this work of Ispos has won global recognition and there should be no hesitation in accepting that urban unemployment is hitting growing numbers of people across the country as the third Covid-19 wave in the form of mutant Omicron spreads fast. The curse of people going without work and therefore, drying up of their income is being increasingly manifest in rural areas too.

The job data report by the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) saying unemployment rate in the country touched a four-month high of 7.91% in December comes as confirmation of popular concern of lack of employment opportunities. It will be poor consolation to say that the country had experienced an unemployment rate of 8.3% in August.

According to CMIE, the urban unemployment rate in December rose to 9.30% from 8.21% in the previous month. In rural areas, unemployment rate during the period was up from 6.44% to 7.28%. Remember people living in rural areas constitute close to 70% of the country’s population. This should give an idea of hardships of rural people without ownership of land. CMIE report says new jobs were created in December, but these were far less than people joining the ranks of jobseekers.

“Around 8.3 million additional people were looking for jobs. However, 4 million jobseekers got employment,” says CMIE managing director & CEO Mahesh Vyas. What is happening on the employment front is not surprising against the background of muted economic activity and consumer sentiment downed by Omicron. From an ill-advised demonetisation that badly hit the informal sector and a fairly large part of building construction activities across the country to clumsy rollout of GST, a number of policies were found to be anti-job growth.

State Bank of India says in a recent report that progress of formalisation of the economy has seen the share of informal sector in GDP falling from 52% in 2017-18 to 15-20% in 2020-21.The report has found that ₹130 million crore has come under the formal economy in the last few years. Formalisation is to be welcomed, for it brings increases in output and turnover by firms, which are liable to pay taxes. Cash intensity of the economy will continue to diminish as the government continues to give thrust to cashless transactions, promote digital payments and kisan credit cards and transfer of all kinds of cash benefits to beneficiary bank accounts.

ALSO READ: Covid Has Deepened India’s Poverty Pit

While all that is good for the economy, the question remains as to what extent job losses in the informal sector have been made good by creation of new jobs in the formal sector. Precise figures are not available. But one can easily guess the privation of people who became redundant in the process of emasculation of informal sector gaining pace since the breakout of Covid-19. No wonder more and more faces of jobless Indians stand frazzled.

The unemployment situation being so critical, New Delhi is pushing profit-making public sector undertakings to take up major capital expenditure programme along with green signalling construction of new highways and other infrastructure projects. At the same time, the banks are encouraged to fund private sector greenfield projects and also its expansion at present operating sites. Infra work is always employment intensive, though not of permanent kind. At the same time, because of high levels of automation and digitisation, investments in manufacturing industries are now generating lesser number of jobs than before.

Let’s consider the ArcelorMittal Nippon Steel (AMNS) announcement to build a massive 24 million tonne (mt) steel plant in Kendrapara district of Orissa (since renamed Odisha) at an investment of over ₹10 million crore. The joint venture company will run the plant permanently employing only 16,000 people. No doubt, the proposed steel plant will create significant indirect employment opportunities several times bigger than direct employment in the mother plant through ancillary and downstream industries and services. But compare the direct employment to be created by AMNS investment at Kendrapara with Tata Steel’s 31,189 people on roll (2020-21 annual report figure). The more than a century old Tata Steel has capacity of 19.6 mt at its three mills at Jamshedpur and Odisha.

Odisha chief minister Naveen Patnaik is aware that the state’s rich endowments of mineral resources, including iron ore, coal, chromite manganese ore and bauxite must not only be used to make primary metals such as steel and aluminium but these must be further value added within the state to generate employment for the local people and revenue for his government. That is why at the prodding of Patnaik, the National Aluminium Company and Vedanta Aluminium are building aluminium parks adjacent to their smelters where small and medium units will get liquid metal to make value added aluminium products.

Vedanta Aluminium CEO Rahul Sharma says his company promoted aluminium park will bring in “investment of at least ₹2,000 crore, create an annual incremental economic value of ₹4,500 crore for the state and generate livelihood for more than 10,000 people.” Steel mills and aluminium refineries and smelters in Odisha are found in areas where tribal population is in majority. Ancillaries linked to mother plants and downstream units for value addition to primary metals create many jobs but they need skilled hands. Here the state – in this case Odisha – will have to build institutions in concerned districts to impart skills to tribal and people belonging to Scheduled Castes and Tribes to be ready to work in factories.

India’s rapidly expanding information technology sector, fintech, which is inviting considerable support from venture capitalists and start-ups mounted on IT are the exceptions where supply of human resources are to fall short of growing requirements for at least the next five years. The country’s largest staffing solutions provider Teamlease says fulltime employee attrition in the technology industry will rise to 22% by March 2022 when attrition in contract staffing will be 49%. Shortages of IT and engineering human resources leading to high rates of job hopping are a global phenomenon that is not going to go away any day soon. At the same time, the problem is manifest more in India and other sourcing countries than destination places such as the US and Europe. In their desperation to retain talents, many Indian employers in IT and e-commerce industries are increasingly resorting to the practice of making better offers to people who have served notice to quit. The practice, however, in many cases is proving counterproductive. With counteroffers in hand, the ones having decided to leave in any case get a handle to strike a better deal with new employers.

The counteroffers could result in demoralisation of performers who are not looking for greener pastures. The competitive bidding game is a no-win practice. Shortages of human resources in the specialised niche sectors call for colleges, universities and IITs to raise capacity to produce larger number of IT experts. At the same time, the IT groups and manufacturing companies digitising their operations will have to have bigger budgets for employee up-skilling.

MORE OPINION
5 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Krishna Rupam
Krishna Rupam
9 days ago

The three waves of Covid-19 have worsened the unemployment situation in India and many other countries. The crisis, as the author says, is particularly manifest in the informal sector. The woes of migrant workers are unimaginable. I wish the article has thrown some light on it. No doubt digitalisation of traditional industries like steel and aluminium and mining sector will lead to redundancies on some scale. But how do the ones becoming surplus in all these sectors find alternative employment? The government and industry will have to spare a thought for them.

Sarvadaman Ray
Sarvadaman Ray
8 days ago

Multiple waves of Covid infections has ensured that the global economy is in turmoil and the recent IMF projections of global growth declining till 2024 is a major issue.
However the global trend of working from home,the internet businesses blooming, there is a major shift of the workforce from traditional jobs to new jobs that are being created which probably is not in the radar of traditional methods of collection of data on employment.
Even the developed world is not aware of the shift in workforce from traditional industries to new industries being created on the cloud.
So for India also, the picture is not as bleak as the author has based his data on traditional sources. The various Government programmes will also play a part in creating employment which is currently not being recorded to a large extent.
Inspite of this India still remains one of the fastest growing economies in the world as per IMF and would become the fastest growing economy by 2023 as per IMF projections

Kunal Bose
Kunal Bose
8 days ago

Renowned financial journalist Rabindranth Sinha says: “The article enlightens us on how employment opportunities are shrinking when the number of jobseekers is increasing. The disesase continues to add to complications. Some India-specific initiatives cannot be avoided and in this, involvement of labour economists in policy formulation may help. Chief minister Naveen Patnaik’s proposal is to be welcomed. CMIE’s data have corroborated some Isos survey findings. Lucidity marks the article.”

Sankar Ray
Sankar Ray
6 days ago

Whenever I read any essay/article on unemployment, I recollect words of Rev Fred Shuttleworth at the historic of over 250,000 inter-racial masses in Washington. ‘ We’re going to march. We’re going to walk together. We’re going to stand together. We’re going to sing together. We’re going to stay together. We’re going to moan together. We’re going to groan together and after a while, we will have freedom, freedom, and freedom now’. Rev Martin Luther King Jr. delivered his uforgettable speech.
Kunal Bose’s facts-studded piece, ‘India’s job-creation chalenge’ backed with commendable piece, made me remember these words. It is a pity that the more the the modern technology, the less the direct jobs. Obsessive and anti-human craze for technology robs job-seekers of their freedom to get jobs while jacks up profit. Bose cites  Arcelllo Mittal groups 24 mlllion steel plant project in Orissa at an estimated cost of Rs 10 million crore which will create 18000 jobs meaning Rs 6.25 million per employment. This is atrocious.
 
Unemployment situation is more worrisome than those worked by IPSOS ir CMIE as a considerable portion of employed persons are under-paid, meaning partially unemployed, let alone ‘disguised unemployment’ that is no more restricted to agriculture. Moreover,  environmental imperatives are pooh-poohed in many investments. For instance, investment in the aluminium sector is among the most polluted onc – particularly from bauxite mining to alumina. Chemicals and Allied Products Expott Promotion Council has ben proud of alumina exports without caring for the mega-ecocide. Settimg up of such industries without consent of people living in those areas (bauxite)mining. We hope Bose and others would focus on these issues in the near future.
Sankar Ray, Kolkata

We use cookies to give you the best online experience. By agreeing you accept the use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.

Privacy Settings saved!
Privacy Settings

When you visit any web site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Control your personal Cookie Services here.

These cookies are essential in order to enable you to move around the website and use its features. Without these cookies basic services cannot be provided.

Cookie generated by applications based on the PHP language. This is a general purpose identifier used to maintain user session variables. It is normally a random generated number, how it is used can be specific to the site, but a good example is maintaining a logged-in status for a user between pages.
  • PHPSESSID

Used on sites built with Wordpress. Tests whether or not the browser has cookies enabled
  • wordpress_test_cookie

In order to use this website we use the following technically required cookies
  • wordpress_test_cookie
  • wordpress_logged_in_
  • wordpress_sec

Decline all Services
Accept all Services
4
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x