‘Prolonged Protest Has Taken its Toll on Farmers at Many Fronts, But Our Resolve Stays Firm’

Gurpreet Singh Sangha, a leader of the Kisan Mazdoor Morcha (KMM), remains resolute in the face of state repression and harsh weather condition. In an exclusive conversation with LokMarg, Mr Sangha spoke about how the protesters have been holding firm despite numerous challenges; how their confidence remains unshaken and; why they are fighting only for victory, not for compromise.

Q: Despite so many challenges, where do you and the other farmers find the motivation to continue this movement?

Gradually, every farmer, labourer, and indigenous person is realizing that this fight is not just about crop prices. Nor is it merely against the government. The common farmer now understands that the real battle is for the survival of the farmer community, land, and generations to come—beyond caste, religion, and region. This fight is actually against the corporate Leviathan. In this “David vs. Goliath” struggle, we draw inspiration from our own historical farmer movements and global agrarian struggles.

The public might not fully grasp this, but organized farmer unions and labour groups have understood that this fight is against the systematic dismantling of the rural economy—forcing displacement from villages and providing cheap labour to corporations.

History has shown that governments can suppress caste- and religion-based conflicts using the “divide and rule” strategy. But when it comes to class struggles, when an oppressed class rises in protest, governments have always lost. What is different this time is that every protester knows this struggle will be long and difficult.

The truth is that the farmer-labourer-indigenous struggle is now a continuous process, not a seasonal movement. While the previous protest was more farmer-centric, this time the demands of labourers and indigenous groups are officially included in our “Demand Charter.” The widespread support and geographical reach of the movement give us greater confidence in our victory.

Q: How has life at the protest sites changed over time and what are your biggest daily challenges?

All four seasons have passed. It has now been a full year since Farmers’ Protest 2.0 began.

Since we already experienced the difficulties of the first farmers’ protest, we were prepared for the hardships, obstacles, and challenges this time. The resources belong to the farmers themselves—each tractor-trailer and tent is stocked with food supplies, and the surrounding villages and gurudwaras provide immense support, ensuring an uninterrupted supply of milk, curd, and langar. So, no challenge has been unbearable.

However, one major challenge in Farmers’ Protest 2.0 is that our message is not reaching a wider audience. This time, the government has not only silenced mainstream media but has also cracked down on independent journalists and YouTubers. As a result, even though the country’s oldest and busiest highway, GT Road, has been blocked for a year and thousands of farmers are protesting at three major sites, most of the country is unaware of it. The only way to counter this information blockade is through “big money,” which the protesting farmer organizations simply do not have.

Another challenge—though not limited to farmers alone—is the judiciary. Previously, the courts turned a blind eye or remained indifferent to farmers’ suffering. Now, they are openly siding with the government. We have no hesitation in saying (even if it amounts to contempt of court) that the judiciary’s stance has been against the farmers this time, consistently ruling in favour of the government. If the judiciary had been independent, the government would have already been forced to meet the farmers’ demands.

Last time, the government did not cross all limits of repression. But this time, unarmed farmers have faced expired and toxic tear gas, pellet guns, and even live bullets. Yet, the Supreme Court has ignored its responsibility. So far, 44 farmers have lost their lives in this movement, and hundreds have suffered severe injuries requiring hospitalization. Even for this authoritarian regime, this is a new low.

Q: How many farmers are actively protesting now, and how has participation changed since the movement began? Which major demands remain unfulfilled, and how do you assess the negotiations so far?

Currently, thousands of tractor-trailers and tents are stationed at three major protest sites—Shambhu Border, Khanauri Border, and Ratanpura Border—forming protest camps stretching for kilometers. Depending on the crop season and action plans, daily participation ranges from 5,000–7,000 people, swelling to hundreds of thousands on key days. Around 150 small and large farmer organizations and unions across the country are affiliated with both the Kisan Mazdoor Morcha (KMM) and the Samyukta Kisan Morcha (Non-Political) [SKM (NP)].

Last time, when the farmers had the government cornered, it immediately repealed the three “black laws.” However, it only provided an official letter promising to address the remaining demands soon. After two years of complete inaction, the government’s indifference forced farmers to restart the movement on February 13, 2024.

Since the initial talks in early 2024, the government did not engage in any further dialogue for a year. Now, sensing the movement’s growing strength and the pressure created by S. Jagjit Singh Dallewal’s hunger strike, discussions resumed on February 14. But in every meeting, the government has used statistics to stall and delay the talks.

The biggest demand is the legal guarantee of MSP (Minimum Support Price), along with nine other demands (attached).

Q: How has this prolonged protest impacted the livelihoods and families of the farmers involved?

There is no point in sugar-coating the truth. The reality is that both organizationally and personally, it is a huge challenge to fight such a ruthless and authoritarian regime. Contrary to government propaganda labeling us “Khalistani,” “Naxalite,” or “foreign-funded,” every single protester is fighting on their own or with the support of their community. The physical and mental toll is immense—not just on the protesters but also on their families and supporters, as the government has been oppressing them too.

Living on the roads under such harsh conditions has severely affected many farmers’ health, and some have suffered physical breakdowns.

Though different unions send their members in rotation to the protest sites, it still creates difficulties for families back home. However, whether in the previous movement or this one, not a single farmer has abandoned their crops. Despite being at the protest sites, planting and harvesting have continued, thanks to the support of neighbors and fellow villagers. But farmers and labourers have been unable to spend time with their families.

Q: Looking back, do you consider this struggle successful? How do you measure its success?

The same leader who has never reversed any of his decisions, who did not acknowledge his mistakes even when demonetization and COVID mishandling led to thousands of deaths, who has clamped down on even major business houses to benefit a few cronies—that very leader was forced to bow before the farmers. This alone gives us the confidence that if we remain united, no force can defeat us. That is our victory.

Right now, the government is trying to reintroduce the same three black laws (or even worse policies) in a different form. But this ongoing movement is a roadblock to those attempts. That is our victory.

Even though the movement continues, one fact remains clear—whenever farmers have united, governments have had to retreat. This struggle is not just about laws or policies; it is about preserving the very existence of India’s farmers and rural communities. And as long as that fight continues, victory is inevitable.

‘Govt Can’t Make Farmers Protest Fail,’ says Farmer Leader Sarwan Singh Pandher

Farmer leader Sarwan Singh Pandher appealed to the residents of Punjab and Haryana to reach the Khanauri and Shambhu border in large numbers as the farmers’ protest completed ten months.

Speaking to ANI, Pandher said “I appeal to the residents of Punjab and Haryana to reach the Khanauri and Shambhu border in large numbers as our protest has completed 10 months. The government agencies are trying to create a confusion among people and are spreading among the people that the protest cannot be won. Haryana MP Ram Chander Jangra is making irresponsible statements on the protest and I urge the BJP President JP Nadda to expel him from the party or take action against him and he should apologise for his remarks made… “

Further, the farmer leader said that their movement is for the people of India and that the BJP could not make the farmers protest fail.

“The people of India are the largest. The BJP is forgetting that they cannot make the farmers protest fail. We will show the ‘kala chehra’ of the BJP government. the open letter that we have written to the government has left them worried. People are joining the protest in large numbers which is why the BJP government is more worried…the 101 farmers are ready to give their lives for the country. we will fight against this torture the government with patience.

Earlier on December 12, Pandher had slammed the BJP-led central government and accused it of not fulfilling the promises made to the farmers. He added that the protesting farmers at the Shambhu border have not received any proposal from the Centre for negotiations on their demand.

“It has been 305 days since Delhi Andolan 2.0 started and seven days since the ‘Amar Anshan’. The ministers are making irresponsible statements,” Pandher told ANI. (ANI)

No Bharat Ratnas For Farmers

No Bharat Ratnas For Farmers!

At the Shambhu border, one farmer shouts out loud on the microphone: “The wait is over, here it comes. Get it man. Get it.”

Two kites are flying high. One quickly does a rapid gota; in kite-language it means a fast, sharp and swift spiral downwards, which only a rare and expert patangbaaj, trained to fly kites in the gullies and terraces of small towns and village mohallas, would know. The kite dips like a rocket and there is a huge cry of joy: “Got it.”

The drone has been trapped by the kite. Earlier, the drones were dropping tear gas like bombs, a first in Indian history.

This is not a fly-in-the-sky game. This is a virtually a war waged by the Indian State against thousands of peaceful and unarmed farmers protesting for a just Minimum Support Price (MSP), a long-standing demand in a market dominated by capitalist sharks aligned to the ruling regime in Delhi.

Last we heard about drones was in Gaza. Certain journalists, ordinary folks, mothers and kids, they were targeted and murdered by Israeli drones. While India, under this current regime, whose PM has publicly displayed his bonding and bonhomie with Benjamin Netanyahu, is one of the largest importers of arms from Israel, the use of drones against the civilian population is a first in India. Earlier, all US presidents, including Barack Obama, have used drones to target ‘terrorists’ in Afghanistan and the Middle-East, with scores of civilians also murdered as ‘collateral damage’ – a normal war-tactics for the Americans, now done at a mass scale by its close ally, Israel, with American guns and bombs.

Not only drones, as during the great and glorious struggle of the farmers in 2021, through rain, sunshine, freezing cold and a scorching summer, for months, the farmers had braved tear gas, lathi-charges, water cannons, armoured barricades, and huge metallic nails, cement barricades, and multiple blockades during the protracted peaceful struggle against the farm bills. These are the same tactics once again being employed at the Delhi border. Now, they are reportedly using pellets as well, used repeatedly and ruthlessly in Kashmir earlier. Three farmers have lost their vision, according to reports.

The notorious farm bills were widely seen as another brazen ploy by the PM to privatise agriculture and vast tracts of fertile land owned by the farmers into a cash-rich fiefdom for certain crony capitalist buddies, namely from Gujarat. Finally, they lost the battle. The bills were repealed – but the promises were not kept.

Significantly, the farmers are demanding, since long, that the MS Swaminathan Committee report on MSP should be implemented. The ruling regime has continuously back-tracked on this crucial issue which is at the core of the economic well-being of India’s hard working farmers. Why? And why is the PM so afraid to allow the farmers to peacefully protest at Jantar Mantar in Delhi – which is their constitutional right?

One lakh crore was lost by the government in year 2021 due to tax concessions and corporate subsidies to industrialists. Ports, mining, forests, airports, etc, apart from huge multi-million projects, are being dished to out to certain favourite industrialists, thousands of crores have been spent on the Ram Mandir, the Sardar Patel statue in Gujarat, a particular stadium named after the PM in Ahmedabad, and the new Parliament building. So, why deny their economic rights to the annadatas, pending for so long?

In a season when it has been raining Bharat Ratnas, agricultural scientist and one of the founders of the botched-up Green Revolution in north India, Swaminathan was given the Bharat Ratna. The move has flopped miserably. His daughter, economist Madhura Swaminathan, has openly come out in support of the farmers proving that not all have sold their soul in ‘totalitarian’ India.

“The farmers of Punjab today are marching to Delhi. I believe, according to newspaper reports, there are jails being prepared for them in Haryana, there are barricades. All kinds of things are being done to prevent them (from entering Delhi). These are farmers; they are not criminals,” she said at the Indian Agriculture Research Institute in an event to mark the Bharat Ratna for her father.

“I request all of you, the leading scientists of India… (we) have to talk to our farmers. We cannot treat them as criminals. They are our annadatas. You have to find some solutions. I request, if you have to honour MS Swaminathan, we have to take the farmers with us with whatever strategy that we are planning for their future,” she said.

ALSO READ: Why Are Indian Farmers Protesting Again?

Narasimha Rao, former Congress PM, unleashed crony capitalism, liberalization, structural adjustment, and the sell-out to West-dominated global financial agencies like the IMF and WTO, with Manmohan Singh as finance minister. He also played blind and deaf while the Babri Masjid was being demolished by the foot-soldiers of LK Advani, while the current PM, then a RSS pracharak, was at Advani’s side. December 6 was then called a ‘black day’ by an outraged nation and the entire media, even by those who have now been running non-stop eulogies on TV and print media on the grand ‘pran pratishtha’ ceremony at Ayodhya.

Now, even Rao has got the highest official award in the land which is an open admission of his complicity in the demolition of the mosque in Ayodhya, while being a lackey of Western-global predator capitalism in India. Unabashed loyalty to billionaire businessmen, and the polarizing Hindutva card unleashed, mixed with a dose of fake ‘social justice’ for the backwards – this is the triple whammy which the ruling regime thinks would result in total victory in the Lok Sabha polls of 2024.

However, even the most cunningly crafted script can turn sour. The award to Chaudhry Charan Singh seemed to have pushed his grandson to suddenly start glorifying the PM, with the possibility of him joining the NDA alliance. The last farmers’ struggle had unified the Muslims and Jat kisans in western UP once again, after they were communally polarized by poisonous social engineering before the 2014 Lok Sabha polls. Har Har Mahadev and Allah-o-Akbar became united slogans of the farmers during the movement.

The same farmers are holding a mahapanchayat and might join forces at the Shambhu border. The farmer struggle has decisively spilled into Punjab, Haryana and Western Uttar Pradesh – a bad omen for the PM weeks before the parliamentary polls. Western UP was never a Hindutva stronghold. Hence, the award given to Charan Singh to appease the jat farmers seems to have failed its purpose.

Indeed, there have been indications that despite the hype and hyperbole on the Ram Mandir in the Hindi heartland, it’s not really becoming a win-win trump card among a wider audience. More so, the Supreme Court judgment on electoral bonds, has come as a shock to the PM and his party. All the big money names would be soon displayed on the Election Commission website. The freezing and de-freezing of Congress accounts, yet again unprecedented in the history of Indian democracy, was therefore a desperate move to divert attention. It boomeranged.

Clearly, it is not all hunky dory for Modi and his men in the days to come. There have been huge protests against the EVMs in Delhi, largely unreported in mainstream media. With thousands of civil society groups and people’s movements working on the ground, the vengeful ED raids and hounding of Opposition leaders creating widespread discontent and anger, and the stupendous response to Rahul Gandhi’s yatra, the Hindutva kite which was flying high after its victory in three cow-belt states, seems to be losing steam.

However, it is a fact that the poison of hate has spread deep in the social fabric, especially in many parts of north India, while Uttarakhand has become the latest hate lab. As the polls come closer, a tense undercurrent floats in the in the air. Pulwama is remembered yet again. The tragedy is still simmering. The tears in the eyes of the families have not dried up.

As the old jungle saying goes: when it comes to the insatiable lust for power, anything can happen. Indeed, will India remain a secular and pluralist democracy after the 2024 polls? We keep our fingers crossed.